SFR Acquisition #29 – 19730 Fenmore, An Unbelievable 19% Cash-on-Cash Return Realized
Investment Summary:
We purchased this property with a good tenant with a 5-year history.
The renter agreed to a rent increase of $100 after closing. The acquisitions team flagged many updates as necessary for this property, but advised the managing partners that they could get them all done without removing the tenant, because much of it would be exterior work, such as siding and windows. There was some work in the kitchen area as well.
In fact, we ended up using half of the capital expenditure we earmarked because the tenant did not want the kitchen updates that were offered. The tenant still agreed to a rent of $1,000.00 starting August 1, 2025 after repairs were completed to her satisfaction.
Zillow has the property valued at above $60,000 in November 2025.
That would bring the equity growth close to 30%, which is an extraordinary outcome, based on the fact that we started cash-flowing from day one, with no downtime.
The simple return on capital for this property (pending property tax revisions) will start at a whopping 19%. Again, this may readjust as property taxes may rise after the change in ownership.